Dunaway Insurance Agency, Inc.

We are pleased to be Licensed in the following States: Indiana, Ohio & Kentucky

Insurance coverage cannot be bound or changed via submission of any online form/application provided on this site. No binder, insurance policy, change, addition, and/or deletion to insurance coverage goes into effect unless and until confirmed directly by a licensed agent.

Dunaway Insurance Agency, Inc. is a customer-focused full service Independent Insurance Agency which understands that continued commitment to our family of clients is the key to our sustained success. Our commitment is to provide you with a comprehensive insurance program that affordably protects your hard earned possessions.

We begin your protection at the point of sale by conducting an in-depth risk analysis unique to your insurance needs. We identify your particular areas at risk, review the strengths and weaknesses of each of the many insurance companies we represent, then carefully design a competitive insurance program that has been personalized for your specific insurance needs. This approach not only reduces the likelihood of unprotected loss potential, but also saves your valuable time because we shop the insurance market place for you.

Why Dunaway Insurance Agency, Inc.

  • We work for you: we do not work for an insurance company. Compared to captive agents who work only for the insurance company they represent.
  • We are an independent insurance agency that represents over 15 different insurance companies. We research with these firms to find you the best combination of price, coverage and service.
  • Honesty, integrity, fair claim resolution and prompt service have been, and remains the basis for our success.
  • We are licensed professionals with strong customer and community ties.
  • Customer satisfaction is the key to our livelihood. So, serving you is our most-important concern. – We assist you when you have a claim.
  • We periodically review your coverage to keep up with your changing insurance needs.
  • We have well over 100 years of combined insurance experience working for you to help solve your complex insurance issues.
  • Our office is equipped with advanced automated technology which provides accurate record keeping and prompt service for our customers.

We invite you to Contact Us concerning your specific insurance needs.

Serving families, individuals and businesses conveniently located to the following Indiana Regions, Including: New Palestine IN, Indianapolis IN, Greenfield IN, Shelbyville IN, Rushville IN, Morristown IN, Cumberland IN, McCordsville IN, Greenwood IN, Fishers IN, Beech Grove IN, Lawrence IN, Mooresville IN, Southport IN, Pendleton IN, Fairland IN, Greensburg IN and many more!

Our Team of Insurance


Our focus is to help you make an informed decision about the coverage and policy options you have to be confident in your level of protection and pleased with the process.

Doug Todd

Sales Agent

(317) 861-6776

Tina Todd

Sales Agent

(317) 861-6776

Don Whitesell

Sales Agent

(317) 861-6776

Stephanie Whittaker

Customer Service Agent

(317) 861-6776