Insurance Companies, Claims & Bill Payments

At Dunaway Insurance Agency, Inc. we are pleased to represent the full array of insurance products and services from the following highly-rated companies.

Available within these listings you are likely to see direct links to each carrier’s primary website, online bill payment integration, claim submissions and company-direct telephone information for additional policy service and support.




American Collectors Insurance, Inc. Logo

American Collectors Insurance, Inc.

Company:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
800-360-2277

Anthem Logo

Anthem

Company:

Auto-Owners Insurance Logo

Auto-Owners Insurance

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
888-252-4626

Celina Insurance Group Logo

Celina Insurance Group

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
800-231-2318

CNA Surety Logo

CNA Surety

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
877-672-6115

Foremost Insurance Group Logo

Foremost Insurance Group

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
Auto: 800-274-7865
Property: 800-527-3907

Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company Logo

Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Company Logo

Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Company

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Liberty Mutual Logo

Liberty Mutual

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
833-218-0219

MetLife Insurance Company Logo

MetLife Insurance Company

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Philadelphia Insurance Logo

Philadelphia Insurance

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
800-765-9749

Progressive Insurance Logo

Progressive Insurance

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
800-776-4737

Safeco Insurance Logo

Safeco Insurance

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
800-332-3226
After Hours Service: 888-481-6876

State Auto Insurance Companies Logo

State Auto Insurance Companies

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
800-766-1853
Glass Only: 888-504-4527

The Hartford Logo

The Hartford

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
Auto: 800-243-5860
Auto AARP Members: 877-805-9918
Home: 800-243-5860
Home AARP Members: 877-805-9918
Commercial: 800-327-3636

Travelers Logo

Travelers

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
Personal: 800-252-4633
Commercial: 800-238-6225
After Hour Service: 877-872-8737

Universal Property And Casualty Insurance Logo

Universal Property And Casualty Insurance

Company:

Bill Pay:

Online Claims:

Claims/Service:
800-425-9113



Serving families, individuals and businesses conveniently located to the following Indiana Regions, Including: New Palestine IN, Indianapolis IN, Greenfield IN, Shelbyville IN, Rushville IN, Morristown IN, Cumberland IN, McCordsville IN, Greenwood IN, Fishers IN, Beech Grove IN, Lawrence IN, Mooresville IN, Southport IN, Pendleton IN, Fairland IN, Greensburg IN and many more!